Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - gctree

Pages: [1]
Wood Turning / Re: Ellsworth Crown Pro-PM gouge jig settings
« on: March 08, 2019, 09:40:13 pm »
Here's my quick and dirty solution I came up with today.  While not elegant, I just sharpened the gouge and it worked great.  Slides onto the side of the tool rest, and the tool rest locks it in position and keeps it from rotating in the same plane as the grindstone.  Slides off the toolrest easily for storage.  I'll try to make another out of less humidity-sensitive materials, as I imagine it will swell and jam once things get less dry in the spring, or at least give it a couple coats of epoxy to seal the wood.

Wood Turning / Re: Ellsworth Crown Pro-PM gouge jig settings
« on: March 08, 2019, 06:28:06 pm »
That looks like it might just be long enough - I think it would need to extend about twice as far from the machine as the standard universal support to allow the jig socket to rest on the universal support instead of extending beyond it like the one I jury-rigged.

Looks like it would be pretty pricey to have shipped to Canada, so I'll put that on the long-term wish list for now...  I could see that coming in handy for other things and it looks really well made.

The wolverine does work perfectly for this application, but it would be nice to have a slicker system for resting the jig on.  Would still be interested to see if anyone has come up with a different way of doing that.

Wood Turning / Re: Ellsworth Crown Pro-PM gouge jig settings
« on: March 08, 2019, 04:08:21 pm »
Thanks Ken. 

I tried a bunch of different projections - going shorter got me closer but still quite far off.  I also played with moving the universal support distance, using different jig settings, as well as flipping the sleeve around to increase the length of the arm.  One of the permutations got quite close to matching the grind, but it wouldn't allow the tool to swing far enough over so missed about 1/4" of the ends of the wings.

I took out my old Wolverine Vari-Grind jig, and very quickly was able to adjust the projection and angle to get the grind to match precisely, removing all of the marker moving my dry grinder by hand (For what it's worth, the Vari-Grind setting that worked was about the same angle as #4 on the SVD-186, but I suppose the reason the SVD didn't match at that setting had to do with the extension of the tool holder beyond the plane of the shaft of the gouge, and the length of the pivot arm).

Then I cobbled together a socket for the Vari-Grind for the Tormek and could easily replicate it.  I would prefer a way to get the SVD 186 to replicate the grind, if anyone has found a setting or hack that can do that, but I think I'll use the Vari-Grind on the Tormek for now for the Crown Ellsworth gouge (I'll still keep honing my other bowl gouges on the SVD 186).

Has anyone come up with a better way of making a socket fixture that extends farther than the universal support?  The only easy solution I could think of was fixing the extension to the SVD 110 tool rest as it locks onto the universal support to keep it from pivoting (picture below).  I first tried drilling a hole in the wooden extension, but because the wolverine jig is angled, the force would rotate the extension on the universal support.  It would be nice to have a universal support with a longer extension to rig something, but making one would be too big a project for me right now...

I'd love to hear any other ideas for that...

Wood Turning / Re: Ellsworth Crown Pro-PM gouge jig settings
« on: March 06, 2019, 11:13:01 pm »
Ken - that's where I was thinking of going next...  but I just remembered I'd read somewhere that the dry grinder jig Ellsworth makes to replicate the grind has a 45 degree pivot arm.  As long as the SVD 186 detents go close to 45 degrees, making another stop beyond 6 might not help.

I figure the only jig variables can be:
1) the angle of the pivot arm
2) the distance from the pivot point to the grindstone
3) the projection of the tool, and
4) the length of the pivot arm

#1, 2, and 3 are easy to adjust with the SVD-186, but I can't think of a way to adjust #4... Adjusting the stop ring is really just another way of adjusting #2.  I think with the Tormek jig #4 is the distance from the centre of the sleeve to where the tool sits in the holder, and to increase it I think you would need to lengthen the tool holder component.  I wonder if that is the adjustment that would be required to match the factory grind?

Wood Turning / Re: Ellsworth Crown Pro-PM gouge jig settings
« on: March 06, 2019, 01:20:57 am »
Hi Rich,

That is a good question.  I would hope that the factory grind is correct, given that Crown charges a very large premium on that gouge just for the grind, compared to their non-Ellsworth 1/2 Pro PM gouge.  As I mentioned, I do have two other bowl gouges that I have sharpened with the Ellsworth jig settings in the Tormek book. I spent the premium on this gouge just to gauge how that geometry cuts compared to the other two - it would be a shame to spend an hour or two grinding away steel to make it the same as the other two before even using it :-\ 

Just for the time savings, given the amount of steel removal needed for those settings, I would probably just freehand it to the factory grind instead. But would much prefer a jig setting that got at least closer to it...

Wood Turning / Ellsworth Crown Pro-PM gouge jig settings
« on: March 05, 2019, 07:38:37 pm »
I have a new 1/2" Crown Ellsworth Pro-PM gouge and was trying to set up the SVD-186 following the Tormek instructions for the Ellsworth grind (75 mm projection, #6, and hole A).

The jig settings get the middle of the gouge bang on, but would make the wings quite a bit higher angle than the factory grind.  In the pictures you can see the gap when the the gouge is on its side, and also you can see where the marker has been worn away in each image - on the sides there's just the smallest sliver near the cutting edge.  I would have to grind a lot of steel away at this setting.

Since I got the gouge mostly as a reference to the Ellsworth grind dimensions for trying techniques in his book, and have two other "non-Ellsworth" P&N bowl gouges already that I've set up with an Irish grind following the "Ellsworth" jig settings in the Tormek book, I would prefer to hone the new one without changing the factory grind dimensions.  My other reason for getting the new gouge was to compare how the Ellsworth factory grind profile compares to my other two in use...  I would prefer to be able to hone to that profile on the Tormek, to prolong the life of the gouge and get a sharper edge. 

It doesn't look like the SVG-186 can be set beyond #6, but maybe that's what would be needed to match the grind?

-Has anyone been able to successfully replicate the grind on the Tormek without freehanding?

Thanks, Jason

Pages: [1]